Minimalist Trading
  1. Home
  2. Learn
  3. Fixed-fractional vs fixed-amount position sizing

Fixed-fractional vs fixed-amount position sizing

Risking 1% of the current balance and risking a fixed $100 behave the same at the start and differently after a losing run. The arithmetic shows how.

  • 6 min read
  • By a.b
  • Updated November 2026

The two rules

  • Fixed-fractional: risk a fixed percent of the current balance, so the dollar risk shrinks after losses and grows after wins.
  • Fixed-amount: risk the same dollar amount every trade, whatever the balance.

Worked example (hypothetical sequence, E)

Account $10,000. Rule A risks 1% of the current balance; Rule B risks $100 (also 1% at the start). Ten losses of exactly 1 R, then ten wins of exactly 1 R:

Step1% of current balance each trade$100 each trade
Start$10,000.00$10,000.00
After 10 losses of 1 R$9,043.82$9,000.00
Then 10 wins of 1 R$9,990.00$10,000.00

After the losses, Rule A has lost less in dollars ($956.18 vs $1,000.00) because its risk shrank with the balance. After the wins, the fixed-fractional account is still $10.00 short of the start, while the fixed-amount account is back to break even: ten losses and ten equal wins leave Rule A below the start, because each loss shrinks the base on which later wins are earned. The same asymmetry is behind why a 50% loss needs a 100% gain.

Trade-offs

  • Fixed-fractional never reaches zero by itself, and it scales risk down in a drawdown. The price is slower recovery from a given sequence, and bigger bets after a lucky run.
  • Fixed-amount recovers symmetrically in dollars, but after a long loss run the same dollar risk is a larger share of what is left, so ruin is possible in a finite number of trades.
  • Prop-firm accounts with a fixed drawdown limit often make a fixed dollar risk the practical choice; see risk per trade in a prop-firm challenge.

Neither rule changes the expectancy of the strategy. Which fits depends on your goals, not on a universal answer.

Using it

  1. Try both in the strategy simulator.
  2. Size the actual trades with the position size calculator.

Trading can lose money. This page is education, not advice.

Pre-set for the market you trade

Pip, point and tick values differ by instrument. These calculators start from each one's contract, with worked examples:

See all instrument calculators →

Quick questions

What is fixed-fractional position sizing?

Risking the same percent of your current balance on each trade, so the dollar risk changes as the balance changes.

Which recovers faster after losses?

In this example fixed-amount sizing returns exactly to the start after equal wins, while fixed-fractional ends slightly below it.

Which is safer?

Fixed-fractional cannot reach zero by repeated losses alone, but both can lose money; neither is safe in itself.

Do they change expectancy?

No. Expectancy per R is a property of the strategy; sizing changes the dollar path.

Keep reading

a.b

Written by a.b. I joined TradingView in December 2015 and publish indicators there. These guides are for education only. Message me on TradingView chat with questions or topics you want covered.

Last updated November 2026. For education only. Not financial advice.